At about 6.00pm on Saturday, 25 April 1998, Cheryl ANTONIO drove her 16 year
old daughter, Rachel Joy ANTONIO to the "Summer Garden" Cinema at the corner of
Beach Avenue and Murroona Street, Queens Beach. As the movie did not commence
until 7.00pm Rachel intended to walk down to the 'stinger nets' at the end of
Beach Avenue, some 200 metres from the Cinema. This she did and was seen leaving
the beach by a number of persons at 6.45pm. She was seen walking on Queens Beach
Esplanade shortly after, but has not been seen since. Rachel is described as
165cm tall, slim athletic build, hazel eyes, fair complexion with sun-bleached
brown shoulder length hair. When last sighted she was wearing a short sleeved,
collarless T-shirt with horizontal blue and white stripes, a green skirt above
the knee with large brass buttons down the front and black dress sandals. Any
member of the public with information which could assist Police is asked to
contact: the Homicide Investigation Group, Brisbane, Phone (07) 3364 6122; any
Police Station; or Crime Stoppers, Phone 1800 333 000.
Bowen schoolgirl Rachel Antonio, 16, was dropped off by her mother at a
cinema on Anzac Day, 1998, and never came home. She was was last seen sitting
alone on a beach 500m away. Her body has never been found.
REWARD: The Minister for Police and Corrective Services has
approved a reward of
$250,000
be offered for
information which leads to the apprehension and conviction of
the person or persons responsible for the
disappearance of Rachel Joy ANTONIO at Bowen on 25 April 1998.
INDEMNITY FROM PROSECUTION: In addition, an appropriate
indemnity from prosecution will be
recommended for any accomplice, not being the person who
actually committed the crime, who first gives such information.
The allocation of the $250,000 reward will be at the sole
discretion of the Commissioner of the Police Service.
Sunday, January 22, 2006. 2:26pm (AEDT)
Search may help solve Antonio case
North Queensland police say the search for a teenager missing from Bowen for
almost eight years, has uncovered several items of interest.
Police, Air Force cadets, fire officers and State Emergency Service crews have
been combing thick bushland on Sandflats at Kings Beach.
They are looking for clues that could help them find Rachael Antonio, who has
been missing since Anzac Day 1998.
The search has turned up several items of clothing and some bone fragments,
which will be tested this week.
Inspector Warren Webber says north Queensland Police continue to receive
information from the public.
The missing girl's father, Ian Antonio, says he has not lost hope.
"We won't give up ... we can't give up," Mr Antonio said.
"Something will come up in the future, we know something will come up.
"Somebody can't disappear off the face of the Earth and nothing ever happen
about it."
Police expect to carry out more searches in the area.
Bone fragments found where teenager went missing
Michael Madigan - Courier Mail
24jan06
BONE fragments and material from clothes have been uncovered in Bowen after
police began a new search for missing Bowen teenager Rachel Antonio.
Police say the bone fragments could be from anywhere but are sending them and
the pieces of clothing for testing.
Nearly eight years have passed since the 16-year-old schoolgirl went missing
from Queens Beach Esplanade in the north Queensland town on April 25, 1998.
Former Bowen Surf Club captain Robert Paul Hytch was found guilty of Antonio's
manslaughter in 2000 but was acquitted on appeal in 2001.
About 60 people including police, State Emergency Service personnel, air cadets
and volunteers scoured about 70ha at the weekend in wetlands east of Queen's Rd
near where the teenager disappeared.
They found clothing and bones but police are not hopeful of any valuable
information.
"It's nothing really significant which will help us solve the case," Detective
Sergeant Mark Inmon, of Bowen, told ABC Radio.
An increase in a reward from $50,000 to $250,000 has encouraged people to come
forward with more information.
"We have checked a lot of ground in the past seven-and-a-half years," Sgt Inmon
said.
Monday, January 23, 2006. 2:00pm (AEDT)
Search for missing teen uncovers bones - ABC
Police are playing down the discovery of bones and clothing during a widescale
search at the weekend for schoolgirl Rachel Antonio, from Bowen in north
Queensland.
The 16-year-old disappeared eight years ago this Anzac Day and her remains have
never been found.
Bowen lifesaver Robert Hytch was convicted and later acquitted of her murder.
Detective Inspector Warren Webber says the area near Kings Beach where the bones
were found is a common dumping ground.
"At this stage there's no great light at the end of the tunnel if you like, we'd
very much like it to bring forth someone who has some additional information and
I suppose one of the side benefits of the search on Saturday may actually be
that it might prompt someone's attention that's otherwise thought that they had
nothing to offer," he said.
The father of Rachel Antonio say he is relieved by the discovery of some bones
and clothes during weekend searches for his daughter.
The samples will be sent away for testing this week.
Ian Antonio says something may have been missed in the initial searches.
"Well, it's a very thick area and little bits of it may have got missed last
time because of the wetlands water, its high tide mark and high tide does come
in here," he said.
"Being so thick and everything else we may have missed little bits of it last
time, we just want to make sure nothing was missed."
Wednesday, January 25, 2006. 11:37am (AEDT)
Antonio investigators reveal bones not human - ABC
North Queensland police say bones found last weekend in a search for missing
Bowen teenager Rachel Antonio are not human.
Rachel Antonio was 16 when she was last seen outside the Bowen cinema eight
years ago.
Northern regional crime coordinator Detective Inspector Warren Webber says the
bones were tested and found to be animal.
"They've been examined and been determined to be all of animal origin, so at
this stage they've been eliminated from our enquiries," he said.
Inspector Webber says clothes found in Saturday's search are yet to be tested by
forensic experts.
Inquest to probe Rachel Antonio disappearance
By Brock Taylor and Sam Burgess - ABC
Updated
Fri Dec 21, 2012
9:29am AEDT
A coronial inquest will be held into the 1998 disappearance
of north Queensland teenager Rachel Antonio.
The 16-year-old disappeared from Queens Beach in Bowen on Anzac Day 1998.
She was dropped at the local cinema by her mother and never seen again.
Dozens of ground searches of the area, as well as the use of cadaver dogs
and aerial mapping found no trace of the girl.
Her boyfriend, Robert Hytch, was initially found guilty of her
manslaughter in 1999 and served nine months of his sentence.
He was later acquitted after a retrial into the case was ordered.
In 2005, police offered a $250,000 reward for information about the case.
A Justice Department spokesman has confirmed an inquest will be held in
Mackay sometime next year.
The former mayor of the Bowen shire council, Mike Brunker, says the town
is still saddened by the case of a missing teenager.
Mr Brunker says the teenager's disappearance affected the entire town.
"The father worked on the council and the mother was well known in the
community," he said.
"In a small community it does affect everybody and this many years of the
unknown is hard to take for the family and of course members of the community."
He says the Bowen community has always held out hope the Antonio family
would find their daughter.
"It's a similar case to the Morcombe family where they finally got closure
after nine years, and to this day the Antonios still wonder what happen to their
daughter Rachel," he said.
Rachel Antonio: Bowen tip dug up in search for missing teen
Chris McMahon, Kate Kyriacou, The
Courier-Mail
THE parents of Rachel Antonio are holding out hope that forensic
officers searching the Bowen dump will find clues in their
daughter’s case.
Ian and Cheryl Antonio met with police at the dump early this morning to
discuss the delicate operation and are optimistic about the dig.
“We met up with (Mackay Detective Inspector) Nikki Colfs out at the
rubbish dump this morning and she explained a bit more of what they’re
doing and how they’re going about it,” Mr Antonio said.
“We haven’t got our hopes up high at all, we are well and truly prepared
that it is a longshot, but as one bloke said, if the body is there,
they’ll find it.
“We can only hope, it’s a longshot … with the forensic scientists that
are around today and the technology, they’ve been digging up old
clothing and old things they’re going to get the barcodes off of things
to try and date it that’s where they’re at, at the moment.”
He said the family had always thought Rachel might be at the dump and
were glad the police were looking into their long held belief.
“Originally we thought if her body was at the dump it would have been
very deep, like 60 metres deep, but then when Hughie (Hugh Smith the
former tip manager in 1998) looked at his diaries he found out that it
wasn’t as deep as he thought it was.
“We felt pretty good that there was a chance we might find something,
that’s the last place we’ve got to look.
“We’ve looked everywhere else, there’s not a place we haven’t looked in
Bowen, we have spent years and years and years, searching every square
inch of Bowen.”
Mr Antonio said the couple want to find out what happened to their
daughter, give her the burial she deserves and try to move on with their
lives.
“We want to find out what happened to Rachel as much as anyone else
wants to find out and they’re doing it.
“We could get on with life again (if we could bury Rachel), and get
living again, that’s what we need to do, we need to put it behind us and
we can’t put it behind us at the moment.”
Earlier, forensic crews are scouring a section of the Bowen dump in an
attempt to locate material from 1998, the same year schoolgirl Rachel
Antonio went missing.
At this point police are calling it an exploratory dig, in a section of
“interest”, to gain an insight into what the waste of the time currently
looks like.
Police began the dig early this morning, using a backhoe, along a pond
in the Bowen dump, digging out a trench in a section that is believed to
have held rubbish from that era.
Forensic officers are then painstakingly sifting through the waste, to
try and find indications of rubbish from 1998.
Mackay Detective Inspector Nikkie Colfs said the dig comes on the back
of maps received from a worker who previously worked at the site, but
wanted to make it clear, they weren’t searching for remains.
“We’re not actually looking for anything at this stage, it’s an
exploratory examination around the age of the refuse during that time
that Rachel Antonio went missing,” Det Insp Colfs said.
“We have a scientific officer here that is gauging the age of the actual
rubbish and that will be done through a whole heap of different
scientific examinations.
“It (further digs) will depend on what they find, how long the refuse
has been here, whether the refuse (has) decontaminated through the last
years.”
Det Insp Colfs could not say whether there would be any further digs
down the track, but said they would await the examination of the
forensic officers following today’s findings.
“At this stage we’re not looking at any further locations, at the end of
the examination today, scientific officers will provide us with some
information and we will have a look at that information that’s given to
us.
At this stage I can’t tell you if there will be further digs, what I can
tell you is at the end of the exploratory examination we will have much
more of an insight in what that’s actually produced.
She said police had spoken with Rachel Antonio’s parents about their dig
and this would not be the final step in their near two decade search for
her body.
“They’ve (Rachel’s parents) actually been advised of what’s occurring
today, they’re happy that police are conducting these examinations.
“The QPS are committed to finding the remains of Rachel Antonio and we
certainly will continue to seek information from the public if they have
any knowledge or information that could assist police.”
EARLIER: POLICE have started digging at the Bowen tip where
Rachel Antonio’s parents believe their daughter’s remains are hidden.
Officers were this morning using a drone to survey the dump. The
exploratory dig will attempt to verify that rubbish in a specific
location is from the period when Rachel disappeared.
Rachel, a 16-year-old lifesaver, vanished on Anzac Day in 1998 after her
mother dropped her off at the local cinema.
She is believed to have been murdered and her disappearance is one of
Queensland’s highest profile investigations.
The coroner found the pair were romantically involved but kept their
relationship a secret.
Rachel’s parents, Ian and Cheryl Antonio, believe their daughter’s body
was left in a skip bin because of the short amount of time available to
hide her.
Detective Inspector Nikki Colfs said 10 officers, including forensic
officers from Brisbane, would be on the one-day exploratory dig.
“We will endeavour to undertake a scientific evaluation of the refuse
and the environmental conditions that were present in 1998,” Insp. Nikki
Colfs said.
“The Antonio family deserve to know what happened to Rachel, and the
Queensland Police Service remains committed to finding her,” Insp. Colfs
said.
Mrs Antonio said she and her husband were glad police were beginning
their search of the tip. “It’s good news,” she said.
“I think if they find anything, they’ll go back to the drawing board and
make a new plan.”
Mrs Antonio said they would not travel to the tip for tomorrow’s
exploratory dig, but would wait by the phone for news. “It doesn’t get
any easier,” she said.
“It would be great if we could find her, give her a funeral, put her to
rest.
“It would mean so much to us.”
Mr Hytch is appealing the coroner’s findings and has long denied any
involvement in Rachel’s disappearance.
A shirt he wore on the night she disappeared — when his movements cannot
be verified for a period of 30 minutes — has never been found and is
among items police would seek to recover from any search.
Rachel Antonio: Family devastated after dump dig plans
abandoned
Kate Kyriacou, The Sunday Mail (Qld)
POLICE have abandoned further searches of the Bowen tip for
the remains of Rachel Antonio after expert advice suggested
there would be nothing to find.
Police conducted a test dig at the site in July following an
investigation by The
Courier-Mail and The
Sunday Mail that revealed meticulous records still existed
pinpointing the location of the area’s rubbish from the time of
Rachel’s 1998 disappearance.
Rachel’s parents, Ian and Cheryl, believe her killer could have hidden
her body in a skip bin.
But experts have told police there would be no value in a dig at the
dump because acidity levels are too high.
The 16-year-old schoolgirl vanished on Anzac Day after her mother
dropped her at the cinema. A coroner last year ruled that it was likely
Bowen Surf Life Saving Club captain Robert Hytch killed Rachel during an
altercation and hid her body.
Mr Hytch was 25 at the time and had been in a secret relationship with
the teen. He has always maintained his innocence and has asked for the
coroner’s findings to be reviewed.
In July, police undertook an exploratory dig at the tip – which was not
searched at the time of Rachel’s disappearance – in an attempt to date
the rubbish as being from the right period. It involved 10 officers,
including forensics specialists from Brisbane, and heavy machinery.
But The Sunday
Mail can revealthere are no plans to explore the site further after
police were told a further dig would be very costly and was unlikely to
lead to the discovery of any remains due to high acidity levels.
“The Antonio family deserve to know what happened to Rachel, and the
Queensland Police Service remains committed to finding her,” Detective
Inspector Nikki Colfs said at the time.
A further blow to the search came when Det Insp Colfs was stood down
from the QPS over an unrelated internal investigation.
Ian Antonio yesterday said the family was not surprised there wouldn’t
be any further searching.
“Really, there’s not much they can do,” he said. “It’s disappointing,
but we worked out that if she’s there, she would be 60m deep.
“If there was anywhere else to search, we’d be there digging tomorrow.”
Mr Antonio said the family’s focus was now on the outcome of Mr Hytch’s
application to review the coroner’s findings about Rachel’s
disappearance.
“This is never-ending for us,” he said. “How long is it going to go on
for? Everyone is broken hearted for us.
THE man a coroner concluded was probably responsible for the
disappearance and death of 16-year-old Rachel Antonio is trying to have
the record scrubbed.
Toby Mann
AAPMARCH
19, 201812:33PM
A MAN found likely responsible for the death of missing teenager Rachel
Antonio wants the Supreme Court to overturn the findings of an inquest.
In opening Hytch’s application for a judicial review on Monday,
barrister Glen Rice QC said they would be arguing the inquest was
conducted under the wrong act.
The inquest was held under the 2003 Coroners Act but Mr Rice has told
Justice Peter Applegarth it should have been conducted under the
previous iteration of the act, which was from 1958.
“There was jurisdictional error from the outset,” he said.
Further, Mr Rice argued, the coroner’s findings were not reasonable,
based upon the evidence heard during the inquest.
An inquest into her disappearance was held after former surf lifesaver
Robert Hytch was acquitted of her manslaughter at a retrial in 2001.
The coroner found Ms Antonio was in a clandestine sexual relationship
with Mr Hytch, despite his repeated denials.
The teenager died after a physical altercation with Mr Hytch on the
night she went missing, with a “fake pregnancy” possibly causing him to
become enraged, Mr O’Connell found.
However, the coroner was unable to conclude the exact cause of Ms
Antonio’s death or where her body was.
“Ultimately I cannot determine what Mr Hytch did with Rachel’s body
unless her remains are located,” Mr O’Connell said.
Last July forensic police searched a tip at Bowen looking for the
teenager’s remains.
Police have offered a $250,000 reward for information that leads to the
recovery of Ms Antonio’s remains and investigations are ongoing.
The hearing continues before Justice Applegarth.
Rachel Antonio: ‘Secret boyfriend’ has 28 days to appeal court ruling on
coroner’s findings
HE has fought every step of the way to clear his name. Now the
ex-boyfriend of slain schoolgirl Rachel Antonio has just 28 day left.
THE clock is ticking on how long Robert Hytch has to appeal the
bombshell ruling that upheld findings that he is the likely killer of
Queensland schoolgirl Rachel Antonio.
A 2016 coronial inquest named Mr Hytch as the 16-year-old’s probable
killer after he was convicted but then acquitted of her manslaughter
on appeal. Her body has never been found.
Supreme Court judge Peter Applegarth yesterday dismissed his
challenge to the findings and Mr Hytch now has 28 days apply to have
Queensland’s Court of Appeal consider overturning the ruling. It
will be the only option left to Mr Hytch.
Mr Hytch’s legal team insists the coroner should have acted under
the 1958 Coroners Act, not the 2003 version.
Rachel’s parents Ian and Cheryl Antonio reportedly expect him to
launch the challenge, prolonging their 20-year nightmare.
She was last seen walking along the Queens Beach Esplanade in Bowen,
in the state’s north, on April 25, 1998.
The former surf lifesaver was sentenced to nine years in jail after
he was convicted of her manslaughter in 1999.
But it was later overturned and in June 2001 he was acquitted following
a retrial at Townsville Supreme Court.
Fifteen years later, Coroner David O’Connell found Rachel had been in a
sexual relationship with Mr Hytch — despite his denials — and died after
an altercation with him.
He also found Mr Hytch then likely hid and disposed of her body. Police
excavated the Bowen tip in search of her remains last year, but failed
to find any clues.
Mr Hytch’s team also claimed the evidence did not meet the standards of
proof. But Coroner David O’Connell’s findings were upheld in the
Brisbane Supreme Court on Wednesday when Mr Hytch’s application was
dismissed.
Justice Peter Applegarth found Mr O’Connell applied the appropriate
standard of proof and had jurisdiction to investigate Rachel’s death
under the 2003 Act. “He diligently evaluated a large body of
circumstantial evidence, including evidence which was not available to
the juries at either of the applicant’s criminal trials,” he said in his
judgment.
Justice Applegarth said Mr O’Connell was aware of the fact a “high
degree of satisfaction” was required before he could make the findings
against Mr Hytch. He also acknowledged Mr Hytch had lied about the
nature of his relationship with the girl along with details about his
car breaking down.
“A reasonable decision-maker in the coroner’s position was entitled to
reject key aspects of the applicant’s evidence, and to conclude that the
applicant gave deliberately false evidence,” he said.
Justice Applegarth also found Mr O’Connell had used enough evidence to
support each of his findings.
“Each finding had an evident and intelligible justification,” he said.
“Each finding was one which a reasonable decision-maker could reach on
the evidence which the coroner accepted.”
Rachel faked a pregnancy with Mr Hytch to get back at him for having sex
with someone else, the inquest was told. Around the time she was last
seen alive, Mr Hytch left his brother’s 18th birthday party and had no
one to corroborate his whereabouts for about half an hour. When he
returned he was not wearing his Nike shirt. Tiny drop of Rachel’s blood
were later found on his sandals.
People on the Rachel Antonio Facebook page begged for information that
would see her body returned to her family after two decades of torment.
“Rachel deserves justice,” one person wrote. “He needs to give up
fighting, admit his wrongs and show her family her location,” another
implored.
Rachel Antonio: Secret diary may bring closure to family of missing
schoolgirl
A secret diary found in Rachel Antonio's bedroom may bring
closure to one of Queensland's saddest and most enduring
questions.
The 16-year-old schoolgirl went missing on Anzac Day, 1998 from
a Bowen beach and was never found, presumed killed.
Then 25-year-old surf lifesaver Robert Hytch, believed to have
been Rachel's secret lover, has denied any involvement in her
disappearance.
For almost two decades, and through two separate trials, Mr
Hytch has denied there had ever been anything but friendship
between the pair.
But detectives are now hopeful Mr Hytch could be charged with
perjury, accusing him of lying about the relationship at trial.
If found guilty, he would face up to 14 years in prison.
Officers say Rachel's diary, which was deemed inadmissible at
trial but later shown at a 2016 coronial inquest, indicates a
romantic relationship between the pair.
Mr Hytch was named as the probable killer in findings of a
coronial inquest, published in July 2016
The director of public prosecutions is expected to make a
decision about whether there is enough evidence for police to
pursue purjury charges tonight.
Police and prosecutors will not comment publicly but they've
reassured Rachel's family, that after a rollercoaster two
decades, this is still very much an open case.
"Without the diary, we wouldn't have a leg to stand on," Ian
Antonio said.
"I was talking to the chief investigator this morning ...
nothing's come to fruition at the moment but as I say they're
still working on it."
Rachel's parents are holding out hope for closure.
"It's been very hard but we have to move on and that's what
Rachel would want," Cheryl Antonio said.
Rachel Antonio: police still considering perjury charge against Robert
Hytch
Five years ago it was recommended Robert Hytch face perjury charges for
lying about his relationship with missing schoolgirl Rachel Antonio. Her
parents are still waiting for something to happen.
Police are still considering a perjury charge against former
surf lifesaver Robert Hytch, five years after a coroner
found he had lied to an inquest about the nature of his
relationship with missing schoolgirl Rachel Antonio.
Rachel, 16, disappeared from Bowen in North Queensland in 1998
after she was dropped at the local beachside cinema by her
mother.
Mr Hytch, aged 25 when Rachel disappeared, was found guilty of
her manslaughter in 1999. He was acquitted at retrial.
The former surf lifesaving captain denied being in a secret
relationship with the schoolgirl and has always maintained his
innocence.
In 2016, Coroner David O’Connell found Mr Hytch had been in an
intimate relationship with Rachel.
He also found that Mr Hytch had fatally injured the schoolgirl
and hid her body.
The coroner recommended Mr Hytch be referred to the Office of
the Director of Public Prosecutions for investigation for a
possible perjury charge, relating to evidence he gave about
denials of his relationship with the schoolgirl.
Mr Hytch challenged the coroner’s findings and appealed, but the
Supreme Court upheld the decision.
The Courier-Mail’s 2016 podcast, Searching For Rachel, brought
the schoolgirl’s disappearance back into the arena following the
coronial inquest.
In 2019, The Courier-Mail revealed officers were reinterviewing
witnesses in the case.
Last year a spokeswoman for the Office of the Director of Public
Prosecutions said the DPP had “concluded its consideration of
the matter and it was referred to the Queensland Police Service
for their consideration”.
When asked if police would pursue the perjury matter, a
Queensland Police Service spokeswoman said: “This matter is
still under consideration of the Queensland Police Service.”
Rachel’s distraught parents Ian and Cheryl Antonio said they
hoped for a resolution, but were not convinced there would be
any outcome.
“We went through a lot of time, effort resources to do the
inquiry,” Mr Antonio said.
“If they don’t follow up with what the coroner said what’s the
use of having a coroner’s inquiry?
“We went to a lot of trouble, everybody did.
“If the coroner recommends it (investigations into a possible
perjury charge) and they don’t do anything about it, what’s the
use of having an inquiry in the first place?” he said.